The Amish, a religious group known for their simple living and separation from modern society, can be a source of curiosity for outsiders. One question that sometimes arises is their perspective on race, particularly their attitudes towards Black people. This article explores the complex relationship between the Amish and race, examining historical contexts, religious beliefs, and the realities of interaction in the modern world.

Understanding the Amish requires acknowledging that they are not a monolithic group. There are numerous Amish subgroups, each with varying degrees of conservatism. Additionally, individual Amish people may hold nuanced views on race that are not always representative of their entire community.

Historical Context

The Amish trace their roots back to 16th century Anabaptism in Europe. They migrated to North America in the 18th century, settling primarily in Pennsylvania and Ohio. During this period, slavery and racial prejudice were deeply entrenched in American society. While there is no clear record of Amish slave ownership, they were not immune to the prevailing racial attitudes of the time.

Religious Beliefs

The core tenets of Amish faith emphasize humility, separation from the world, and pacifism. These principles are derived from their interpretation of scripture, particularly the New Testament. The Bible instructs Christians to love their neighbors (Matthew 22:39), a principle that extends to all people regardless of race.

However, some interpretations of Amish doctrine have been used to justify racial segregation. For instance, the concept of Gelassenheit, meaning submission to God's will, has been used to argue for accepting the social order of the time, which included racial inequality.

The Issue of Shunning

Shunning, the practice of ostracizing members who violate community norms, is a complex issue within Amish society. While some believe it is used to enforce racial prejudice, the reality is more nuanced. Shunning is typically reserved for serious transgressions, such as marrying outside the faith or adopting modern technology. There is no evidence that race alone would trigger shunning.

Black Mennonites and Interfaith Relations

It's important to distinguish between the Amish and Mennonites, another Anabaptist group. While they share similar beliefs, Mennonites have a wider range of views on social issues, including race. There are established Black Mennonite communities in the United States and Africa, demonstrating a more inclusive approach to race within Anabaptism.

There is limited documented interaction between Black people and the Amish. Geographically separate communities and differing lifestyles have minimized opportunities for contact. However, some Amish relief organizations, guided by their faith-based commitment to helping others, have provided aid to Black communities affected by natural disasters.

Looking Forward

The Amish way of life is constantly evolving. As the world becomes more interconnected, the Amish will inevitably encounter greater racial diversity. While their commitment to tradition remains strong, there are signs of a more open-minded approach to race within some Amish communities.

This is evident in the increasing number of Amish youth who volunteer with organizations that promote racial equality. Additionally, some Amish businesses have begun to hire non-Amish workers, including Black people.

In conclusion, the relationship between the Amish and race is multifaceted. Historical factors, religious interpretations, and limited social interaction contribute to the complexity of the issue. While there is no easy answer to the question of whether Amish people "like" Black people, a more accurate perspective acknowledges the ongoing evolution of Amish attitudes within the context of their faith and a changing world.

Instances of Inclusion

While generalizations should be avoided, there are documented cases where Black individuals found acceptance within Amish communities.

• Adoption: Some Amish families have adopted Black children. While there can be challenges in navigating cultural differences, these adoptions demonstrate a willingness to extend love and care beyond traditional racial boundaries.
• Individual Relationships: Instances exist of Amish people forming close friendships with Black individuals, based on mutual respect and shared values. These relationships challenge stereotypes and showcase the potential for human connection across racial divides.

Challenges and Tensions

Despite these positive examples, challenges and tensions remain.

• Lingering Prejudices: While overt racism may be uncommon within the Amish, implicit biases and a lack of understanding about Black experiences can still exist. These unconscious attitudes can hinder the development of genuine interracial relationships.
• Cultural Differences: The cultural gap between Amish and Black communities can lead to misunderstandings and miscommunications. Differences in language, customs, and lifestyles can pose barriers to building close bonds.
• Self-segregation: The Amish focus on separation from the outside world sometimes translates into an unintentional form of self-segregation. This insularity can limit opportunities for meaningful interaction with diverse groups, including Black communities.

The Importance of Dialogue

Addressing these challenges is crucial for fostering greater understanding between the Amish and Black communities.

• Education: Promoting education about Black history and culture within Amish communities can help dispel stereotypes and foster greater awareness of the Black experience in America.
• Open Communication : Encouraging opportunities for respectful dialogue between Amish and Black individuals can build bridges and promote empathy.
• Shared Experiences: Facilitating shared experiences, such as community service projects or interfaith gatherings, can create a platform for collaboration and mutual respect.

References

• Kraybill, Donald B., Karen M. Johnson-Weiner, and Steven M. Nolt. The Amish. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2013.
• Moore, Judy. "African American Amish in America." The Charlotte Gazette, 20 July 2023, https://www.thecharlottegazette.com/2023/07/20/judy-moore-african-american-amish-in-america/
• Scott, Stephen. Plain Buggies: Amish, Mennonite, and Brethren Horse-Drawn Transportation. Good Books, 1981.

Let me know if you'd like further development or have a specific aspect you'd like explored in more detail!