Hotel Impossible, the popular reality TV show hosted by hospitality expert Anthony Melchiorri, captured audiences with its dramatic transformations of struggling hotels across the country. However, beneath the inspirational makeovers lies a question: how many of the hotels featured on Hotel Impossible have ultimately closed their doors despite the show's intervention?

In this article, we'll delve into the real-life fates of the Hotel Impossible properties, investigating the factors that contribute to the success or failure of these revamped businesses.

The Success Rate of Hotel Impossible

While Hotel Impossible aimed to revitalize hotels on the brink of closure, the reality of the hospitality industry is harsh. While specific figures on closure rates are hard to pin down, sources like the website "Do Not Book Here" have tracked many hotels from the show and claim that a significant number are no longer in operation.

It's important to note that not all closures can be directly attributed to the show's shortcomings. Various factors may influence a hotel's closure post-makeover, including:

• Management: Owners who don't implement or maintain the changes advised by Melchiorri could see their hotel fall back into old patterns.
• Finances: Undercapitalized hotels may not have the resources for long-term improvements or to withstand unexpected expenses.
• Location and Market: Hotels in less desirable areas or those facing fierce competition could struggle regardless of renovations.
• External Factors: Changes in the broader economic landscape or major events can negatively impact a hotel's sustainability.

Notable Hotel Closures

Several hotels featured on Hotel Impossible have prominently faced closure:

• The Keating Hotel (San Diego): This iconic hotel, featured in season one, experienced a temporary shutdown before being sold to new investors. While it's currently undergoing redevelopment, its future remains uncertain.
• Roosevelt Inn (Idaho): This historic hotel enjoyed a boost following its Hotel Impossible appearance but later closed permanently.
• Silver Beach Hotel (Michigan): This once-dated lakeside hotel closed its doors despite a major renovation on the show.

Success Stories Do Exist

While some Hotel Impossible hotels have closed, there are also instances where Melchiorri's guidance and renovations provided a lifeline. Hotels like the Juniper Hill Inn (Windsor, VT) have found continued success after their appearances on the show. Factors like strong leadership, strategic location, and a favorable market can play crucial roles in ensuring a hotel's continued success after being featured on the show.

The Lessons of Hotel Impossible

The mixed results of Hotel Impossible offer valuable takeaways for both hoteliers and the wider public:

• Hospitality is a tough business: Revitalizing a struggling hotel requires more than just physical updates. Success is contingent on a wide range of factors, from solid management practices to financial resources.
• TV Transformations aren't always enough: Shows like Hotel Impossible offer compelling entertainment and can inspire change. However, sustained success requires ongoing effort and realistic expectations.
• Support Local: If a hotel from the show has remained open in your area, consider supporting them to contribute to their continued success.

Conclusion

While Hotel Impossible showcased Anthony Melchiorri's expertise, the reality of the hotel industry remains complex. Some closures highlight the challenges any hotel faces. While it's tempting to view the show as a magical solution, lasting success within the hospitality industry demands consistent hard work, sound business practices, and a little bit of luck.

References

• Hotel Impossible - Wikipedia
• Do Not Book Here | Hotel Impossible Failures 
• Hotel Impossible: Five Things you Didn't Know about Hotel Impossible... See full article at TVovermind.com